Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Rabbi Arthur Segal’s love of people, humanity, and Judaism has him sharing with others “The Wisdom of the Ages” that has been passed on to him. His writings for modern Jews offer Spiritual, Ethical, and eco-Judaic lessons in plain English and with relevance to contemporary lifestyles. He is the author of countless articles, editorials, letters, and blog posts, and he has recently published two books:
ALL ENTRIES ARE (C) AND PUBLISHED BY RABBI ARTHUR SEGAL JEWISH SPIRITUAL RENEWAL, INC, AND NOT BY ANY INDIVIDUAL EMPLOYEE OF SAID CORPORATION. THIS APPLIES TO 3 OTHER BLOGS (CHUMASH, ECO, SPIRITUALITY) AND WEB SITES PUBLISHED BY SAID CORPORATION.
Monday, January 14, 2008
The Best Gift
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Tuesday, January 8, 2008
Tu B'Shvat: The Jewish New Year for Trees
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Sunday, January 6, 2008
Talmud Discourse 25 'Yerushalmi',"Kiddush cup"
(Between the recital of the benediction before eating and ingesting the food, we do not interrupt with idle chatter. Such a disruption would require the recitation of a new blessing, for the benediction previously said is rendered invalid by the interlude, according to the Talmud.
Our sages explain that certain pertinent phrases may be said in the interim, since they are not considered a digression of thought (B. Berachot 40a). Thus one who pronounced the benediction over bread but is yet to taste the food, can pass a piece of bread to someone else and say: "Take, recite the blessing." According to another sage, even if the one who recited the blessing said: "Bring salt, bring relish," the initial blessing is not rendered null. The final opinion brought in the talmudic passage allows one to even say "Mix the food for the oxen," without voiding the initial blessing. It is a commandment in Judaism to feed our animal before ourselves.)
The cup was held high, the same way the priests would hold the sacrifice high, acknowledging G!D in His heavens and for the people to see. It elevates the mundane grape and wine, into a holy act.
I will end with the why the use of the right hand.
As we have learned and studied, the Talmud, redacted in its Mishna from circa 200 CE and in its Gemorah additional form in circa 500 CE was a 1000 year old text derived from oral tradition, predating in some areas, back to Torah, perhaps. Each rabbis opinions were recorded, none were censored, and even when they were angry at each other and called each other names, this was included. In times of peace, since rabbis are humans, we read peaceful wisdom, and in times of tribulation, we can sense the bitterness in the pages.
Rabbi Aha was one of the Savorai Rabbeinu, who lived near the end of the 4th century CE. Jerusalem was vanquished by the Romans 300 years before, and Christianity, was now the state religion of Rome, who controlled what was left of Eretz Israel. Rabbi Aha loved life. The rabbinic rule forbidding dancing was ignored by him [Bava Betsa 30] but the immodesty of concentric male and female circles, carried the day. Ignored was Ketubbot 17a, which described Rabbi Aha dancing with a woman on his shoulders. Kiddushin 82 teaches that intent and not the fact of contact, when between male and female who are not married or dating, determines propriety. This point tends to be lost on some of our Jewish sects today.
Rabbi Aha was no fan of Rome nor of Christianity, as both were oppressive to Jews. Rabbi Aha declared: "there was a man, the son of a woman, who would rise up and seek to make himself God, and cause the entire world to err . . . . If he says that he is God, he lies; and in the future he will cause to err - that he departs and returns in the end. He says, but will not do . . . . Alas, who shall live of that people that listens to that man who makes himself God?" (Yal. Simeoni on Num. 23:7).
Hence the use of the right arm to raise the Shabbat Kiddush cup was significant to Rabbi Aha. "If I forget thee, O Jerusalem, let my right hand forget her cunning. If I do not remember thee, let my tongue cleave to the roof of my mouth. If I prefer not Jerusalem above my chief joy" (Psalm 137). By remembering Jerusalem, which he could walk by and view in ruins, and by using his right arm, he helped make each Shabbat a reminder of the world to come, when the Temple would be rebuilt, in Jerusalem, and the exiled Jews, would be gathered together in 'the land.'
For liberal Jews echoing the words of Rabbi Gustavus Poznanski , of 1841 Charleston, SC, USA, who was moved to say "This synagogue is our Temple, this city our Jerusalem, and this happy land our Palestine," we can still find meaning in Rabbi Aba's ritual as Shabbat is a spiritual mystical time, and a time when we can step out of the secular, into the holy, and prayer and direct ourselves to do Tikun Olam, to repair the world, as G!d's human partners, for Shalom, tsadakah and chesed.
L'Chaim!!
Shavuah Tov,
Rabbi Dr. Arthur Segal
The Yerushalmi, the Talmud produced in the Land of Israel, is something like
the ugly sister who never gets any attention when compared with the Bavli
,
the Talmud of Babylonia. So this new year, well attempt to address that
wrong. The Yerushalmi has glories to rival the Bavli's ,so let's get
started! (She ends up being quite as pretty as her sister!)
We'll begin with something that just about every Jew owns: a Kiddush cup.
Whether you got it when you were 13 or when you were getting married or you
collect them, the Yerushalmi has this to say about it:
The earlier sages asked: Can the left hand help the right hand hold the
Kiddush cup when we are saying the blessing? We learn from this question
three things:
You must hold the cup in your right hand.
You must hold your hand up at least a handbreadth above the table.
You must pay attention to the cup while saying the blessing it (i.e., you
don't set it down to check the oven, for instance).
Said Rav Aha: Three things were said concerning the Kiddush cup:
It must be full.
It must be decorated.
It must be clean. (Y. Berachot 7:5)
Discussion Questions
First some words on the Yerushalmi. There are two versions: the Venice
edition which has all the tractates in one volume and the P'nei Moshe
edition in 7 volumes. The latter looks more like a page of Bavli. However,
always, in the Yerushalmi, a mishnah is called a halachah, so if you're
looking into the actual text itself, don't let that trip you up.
The only complete translation of the Yerushalmi into English is edited by
Jacob Neusner, entitled, The Talmud of the Land of Israel, in 35 volumes
from University of Chicago Press. You can buy individual volumes, so you
can
go for the tractates which most interest you. Finally, the Yerushalmi has
Talmud on Mishnah tractates that the Bavli does not so we're in for a
fun ride!
Now, to the questions:
1. How does your cup stand up to these standards? (I was appalled, thinking
how much silver polishing I'm going to have to do to bring ours up to
snuff!)
2. Why do you think the cup had to be decorated?
3. Why must you hold the cup in your right hand? Why do you have to hold
it up?Enjoy! R. Abrams
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Reader Comment on ''Koufax'' from ''Talmudic Discussion on Business Ethics ''
Hello Rabbi; not sure what your source was, but just so it's clear, Sandy Koufax did not pitch in the Israel Baseball League this past year. He was 'drafted' by Modi'in, but it was an honorary gesture; he was never expected to really play, and he didn't. He said he was touched by the gesture and appreciative.Marty Appel Public Relations
Celebrating 10th anniversary in 2008
100 W. 57 Street
New York NY 10019
212 245-1772
212 245-6353 (fax)
www.appelpr.com
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Saturday, January 5, 2008
Talmudic Discourse 24: how to make New years resolutions stick...Jewishly
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Talmudic Discourse 23
by tshafer3661
So is it time for ML Baseball to go the way of pro wrestling? Could happen
I guess if the sport continues to be money and ratings driven.
I remember "rasslin' " from the early days on TV in the mid 50's. Gorgeous
George and Haystacks Calhoun. Back in those days they actually used to know
each other around to decide who won. Of course, they had their show stuff
but when they bashed one another on the back with a chair it was real
chair.
I made a friend a few years ago who "rassled" on the minor league circuit in
the Deep South. He assures me there was some improvisation of showy moves
but no choreographed bouts. He recalls vividly getting the stew knocked out
of him in several bouts he lost.
Nowadays there is total choreography of the bout. It starts out week before
with mock tussling and arguments between the fighters, carefully scripted to
enrage the fans. This is where the villain gets especially villainous and
die hard fans fear he will truly defeat their champion of truth, love and
the American way. It build to a crescendo where they do fight in the ring
sort of. Actually they stomp beside the other guy's head and break balsa
wood chairs on each other's back. And they practice the bouts before hand
so all the carefully panned moves including the pin for final victory come
off perfectly.
Now these guys are finely tuned athletes. They look like big muscle bound
men but actually are very talented gymnasts and actors. Nothing as hard to
play as a fight scene. It is just they are no longer competitors because
the final victor is determined before the bout by management as the outcome
best designed to keep the fans flared up and increase attendance and viewing
at the rematch bout.
Of course, the pro wrestlers use steroids too, lots of them. They feel they
need to get that massive physique. A cop friend of mine once told me if you
want to go where the action is in a case, follow the money and the drugs.
Good advice in life I am sad to say.
An interesting part of the discussion appeared in an editorial on sports
medicine in the Journal of the American Medical Association a few years
back. The author pointed out that steroids really have minimal anabolic
intracellular muscle building effect unless your client had a low level in
the first place. A high level can cause growth of things like brain tumors
and liver nodules but the determinant of muscle growth is how much the
muscle is stressed and worked.
Steroids do make the athletes more aggressive so they tend to do more and
faster reps when they work out, leading to muscle growth. However the JAMA
author pointed out that you can accomplish the same thing with a good
trainer who pushes you beyond your self perceived limits. And this is
without the danger of medical problems down the road or more immediate
danger of injury due to excessive exertion.
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Talmudic Discourse (Jewish Business Ethics)
Rabbi Judith
baseball leave us feeling disgusted? Disappointed? Disillusioned? Certainly
we feel a sense of loss regarding the honor and traditions that are so much
a part of baseball and its history.
So, how can we frame this experience? Quite easily. If major league
baseball is to be a legitimate sport something more than professional
wrestling ,then we should hold it to the standards that Judaism sets for
every single one of us in our businesses: absolute honesty.
Rabbinic literature teaches us that we are required to be absolutely hone
st in our business dealings. We may not mix two kinds of produce, even if the
3:26//Sifre Deuteronomy 295)
Indeed, the very first question each person (not just Jews) will be asked
after they die and are facing judgment is, Were you honest in business
?
(Bavli Shabbat 31a). It doesn't get much more basic than that.
I understand the temptation on the part of the players to achieve better
statistics. I understand the management desire to put on a better
show that leads to higher revenues. We always struggle with our urges to have
more. But that the point, we struggle with these urges.
We need the Evil Inclination to urge us to achieve, but it cannot rule us:
to them. God said to the sages: If you kill the Evil Inclination, the world
will fail. They imprisoned the Evil Inclination for three days, then looked
in the whole Land of Israel for a fresh egg and could not find one.
Thereupon they said: What shall we do? If we kill him, the whole world
would fail. They put out his eyes and let him go. (Bavli Yoma 69b)
Perhaps the Evil Inclination was simply allowed to grow too strong. So here
is the way back: we make ourselves stronger than the Evil Inclination
again. We remember who the true hero is. The true hero is the one who
masters his or her Evil Impulse (Pirkei Avot 4:1). We remember the high
level of honesty demanded of us and come back to it feat of strength
that can only be accomplished through strength of will and spirit, not drugs.
And through this exercise of will, we will be able to repair this situation and
baseball can return to its home in our hearts.
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Talmudic Discourse 21 Hanukah-Women
Off the top of my head, I seem to remember a woman who has seven sons die
during the Maccabbean rebellion. Anyone else remember her?
The Ballad of Hannah and her Seven Sons tells a story well known from the Apocrypha II Maccabees 6:12-17. During the persecution of the Jews in Syria at the time of Antiochus Epiphanes (d. 163 B.C.E.), the seven sons of Hannah were commanded to worship an idol. Each refused, and each in turn was slaughtered. The Babylonian Talmud Gittin 57b sets the story in the time of "Caesar," that is, at the time of the destruction of the second temple in 70 C.E. The ballad follows the medieval version of Jossipon in its account of the mother's death. The Judeo-Arabic ballad based on this story appears to have been very popular, and like so many of its type, is "known only in its variants." It is found throughout the eastern dialect area extending from Libya to Iraq, and the western dialect area has a different ballad on the same theme. In the past century or so, the eastern ballad has been printed in such far-flung spots as Calcutta, Bagdad, Aden, Tiberias, Leghorn, Tripoli and Tunis. The version translated here is that printed in Tunis in 1910 by Mardochée Uzan and brother, and sold by him at his "modern bookstore" in Rue Sidi Mardoum, Tunis. At that time Tunis had a large Jewish population, perhaps as much as one third of the inhabitants of the city.
The ballad is chanted on the Fast of the Ninth of Ab, which commemorates the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem on two occasions. On that day, Jewish tradition dictates that only sad and depressing materials may be read, and this includes this ballad which fosters the frame of mind suitable for the occasion.
In the Tunis version given here, Nebuchadnezzar is named as the tyrant. Other versions follow the Talmud and refer to "Caesar." Tradition places this at Hanukah time, as it is in the book of Maccabees and the heroine is named Hannah. This is the eastern version which seems to have reached as far west as Tunis. Its language is somewhat adapted to the Tunisian dialect, but it is probably Iraqi in origin.
In form the poem is a zejel, a kind of poetry brought to its flower by the Spanish Arabic poet Muhammad ibn `Abd al-Malik ibn Quzman, who died in 1160. Characteristic of the zejel is its colloquial language, as well as a typical rhyming scheme: aaab cccb dddb where b rhymes with a constantly recurring refrain of one or two lines. In the version given here the number of syllables per line varies greatly. The strophe has four or five lines. After each strophe the refrain It is proper for us … is repeated.
The poem possesses a pathos which is simple yet compelling, and is somehow not marred by such illogicalities as Hannah's suffering in silence, although she is always talking, and the precociousness of a three year old who demolishes the king's ideology. There is constant contrast between the gruesome physical sufferings of the sons, and the mental anguish of the mother, and there is no doubt that the mother suffers more. Impressive too is the unshakeable faith of the martyrs, who never doubt the justice of God, the rightness of their cause, or the certainty of their reward.
The Ballad of Hannah and her Seven Sons
I am Hannah. Listen to my speech, and look what happened to me.
I had seven sons, whom I cherished and honored and pampered.
Among them was a baby whose face brightened the night.
But they fell into the unbeliever's hands who feared not Almighty God.
It is proper for us to weep all our nights and days! Nebuchadnezzar spoke gently to them and said: "Worship my idol.
Come forward the eldest, intelligent Jew.
Worship my idol, and you will not be slaughtered and laid low.
Listen not to what others say and disobey not my intent,
For if you disobey, woe to you. You will fall like a bird from the sky.
It is proper for us etc. He answered him scornfully: "Listen, king,
I worship only God, creator of mankind.
You are nothing by comparison, for soon you will be in the dust.
Your idol does not profit, nor money, nor images."
He said: "Kill the unbeliever by my leave and on my responsibility."
It is proper for us etc. They grabbed and held the poor man, and tied his hands behind him.
They pulled off his clothes, and threw him into a pit.
They brought his mother to see his severe torture.
He cried out: "Mother, have pity on me by enduring,
For where is the love we bore, Mother who pampered me?"
It is proper for us etc. They brought the second one weeping, his tears running like a flood,
But his heart was strong in the Lord, creator of mankind.
Four men grabbed him, and dragged him to the king.
He said to him: "My child, obey me, get up, worship the image.
Do not listen to what other people tell you."
It is proper for us etc. He answered him: "King, do not prolong your speech.
What are you, you miserable man, and what is your status?
Soon you will perish, and your affairs will be in disarray.
He will destroy all your wealth, and make nothing of your officers."
He said: "Kill the unbeliever, and do not annul my words."
It is proper for us etc. They took the boy, and slaughtered him in his mother's presence.
She cried: "My child" and pressed him to her bosom.
She threw herself upon him, and wallowed in his blood.
She found no one to be close to her and exhort her to patience in her trouble.
"Be sad for me and dwell on my trouble and grief."
It is proper for us etc. They brought the third handcuffed, and his tears were flowing.
He said to him: "My child, obey me in a single matter.
Arise, worship my idol and your days will be long.
We shall raise you to high rank, and give you great power.
If you hear and obey me you will be exalted over all my servants."
It is proper for us etc. He answered him with fine speech. "Pay attention and listen.
Your idol is the work of man. He has ears and does not hear.
He has a nose and does not smell, eyes and does not see.
He has hands and does not grasp, feet and does not walk.
You are like your idol, you ignorant unbeliever."
It is proper for us etc. He condemned him to death and said: "Bring a firebrand.
Take him and torture him, roast and fry his flesh.
He disobeys my religion, he constantly speaks arrogantly.
He despises my idol and mocks my deeds.
Bring his blood to me in haste, hurry up and do not delay."
It is proper for us etc.. They took the poor fellow, mutilated him, and stripped the skin from his head.
They cut off his hands and feet, and threw him next to his brothers.
His mother saw it with her eyes when they drew out his insides.
She could not say a word, but her soul was with his soul.
She wept and cried and said: "Oh, my babies."
It is proper for us etc. They brought the fourth, poor fellow, apprehensive, heart-broken.
He said to him: "My child, obey me, do not disobey my order.
See what your brothers have become, lying unburied.
Obey me, listen to me, and you will escape and get great riches.
I will build you high castles if you do not oppose my will."
It is proper for us etc. The boy spoke up and said to the king: "O tyrant,
We accept upon us the judgment of God, and all of us will die by your sentence.
On account of our sins he has caused this, and cast us before you.
We accept it and will not obey you, and will not serve your images.
We shall worship only our God, who is honored above the mighty."
It is proper for us etc.. The king gnashed his teeth and said: "Kill him speedily with an ugly death."
They slaughtered him in his mother's presence, but she was obedient to God.
They slaughtered the child in her presence, while she suffered in silence.
She looked at him, and was distressed, and said: "Oh, my babies."
It is proper for us etc.. They brought the fifth and he cried in distress:
"Mother, accept God's judgment and do not oppose his decision.
Though he destroy a thousand of us, we will not worship in his manner.
Let God judge as he pleases in all matters."
It is proper for us etc. They stood the child before him, and he said to him:"My child, I inform you
That my idol will profit you and save you from your anxieties."
He answered him thus: "Do not rely on your images.
Soon you will die and pass away, you and all your counsellors,
You are like your idols, soon you will be burned in fire."
It is proper for us etc. The king arose, and stamped his foot and said: "I will not retract."
They took the poor fellow, and tortured him, so that all his flesh felt pain.
In great torture, poor fellow, two days he agonized,
Stretched out two whole days and nights in the sun.
It is proper for us etc. Then they brought the sixth, shackled with iron chains.
And when he saw the idol, his face changed.
He said to him: "O unbeliever, do not speak much to me, but do not overlook what I say.
Kill me quickly. The Lord will take vengeance on you.
I will die rather than disobey the command of God Most High."
It is proper for us etc. The king spoke up and said: "Kill him, and let his mother see."
They slit his throat from ear to ear, and the tears flowed from her eyes.
And she cried out and wept, and her heart could not bear it.
And she cried out and wept and said: "My babies."
It is proper for us etc.. They brought the seventh, poor child, who was only three years old,
And he wept with flowing tears and said: "O master of the worlds!"
His mother bent down behind him and cried in a pleading voice:
"Do not obey them, my precious. Do not let them persuade you against what I say."
It is proper for us etc.. "Arise, young man. Hear and be obedient to my words.
Do not disobey my command and reject my idol and my images.
I shall make your rank high, and make you a leader.
A minister of the realm, a minister of state, you will be chief of my counsellors.
Everything will be yours, prosperity and wealth."
It is proper for us etc. He answered him: "O evil-doer, you are afraid of created things,
And forsake God Most High, living and existing, who is all-powerful.
How can you tell me to worship your images made of wood from the street?
A pity for your intelligence. You have taken leave of your senses."
It is proper for us etc. And he said: "O child, obey me in what I tell you.
I shall put down my ring among the soldiers, next to the idol, I shall throw it down for you.
Stoop and give it back to me, and repeat it twice.
Tell your mother to worship my idol, and you will not be killed or harmed.
Your brothers would be glad, since you are the youngest of all."
It is proper for us etc.. And the king said to the servants: "Bring Hannah before me."
"O Hannah, urge your child to do obeisance to my images.
And we shall make him chief minister, he will be chief of my counselors.
You shall live, your child shall live, only do not disobey my words.
Hannah, tell your child to listen to my commands."
It is proper for us etc. She gave answer to the king: "Include me with my children."
"Precious, do not obey them, my breath, my life,
Look how you were nine months in my womb, my child,
I brought you up and reared you and fed you in my house
Day and night, year after year."
It is proper for us etc. He answered her: "Mother, let me go to them.
Let them do what they want, and what their heart desires.
I am more precious to you than my brothers, so is my death than theirs.
I worship none save one God who is exalted over all others."
It is proper for us etc. She clasped him to her breast, and wept and said:
"My child, my little one, accept the decree of your Lord.
Your place in paradise with all your forefathers is assured.
Our God will judge Nebuchadnezzar, and punish him severely."
It is proper for us etc. They took him from her, and she wept and said: "My little one,
What are my sins, what my deeds, what my behavior?
My Lord has left me neither oldest nor youngest.
Fate has deprive me of them and taken my babies from me."
It is proper for us etc. They slaughtered him in her presence, and she saw it with her eyes.
She fell upon him, and stamped her foot, and her spirit went up to God.
She died for what she underwent, and what happened to her children.
Praise be to Him who desired this. To him is the command and the action.
It is proper for us etc.A voice went out from Heaven: "Happy are you, Hannah,
Paradise is open to you and your seven sons."
Soon he will build our sanctuary, and we shall dwell in it as we were.
All our enemies will perish, and he will pity all our people.
Elijah will come with good news with Messiah, son of David!
It is proper for us to rejoice all our nights and days!Judith's story is also linked with Hanukah.Once Hanukkah festivities included the celebration of two heroes—Judah Maccabee and Judith. Although for several centuries the Rabbis included Judith in their Hanukkah narratives, her story, recorded in the Book of Judith, never made it into the canonized Bible. The Book of Judith promised that her "praise will never depart from the heart of those who remember the power of God," and she acted with a certainty that her legacy would "go down through all generations of our descendants." Neither she nor her contemporaries could have imagined a time when her story, as a story of courage in the face of enormous risks, would cease to be part of the story of the Jewish people passed from one generation to the next.
And yet today, Judith's story is a little-known part of the Hanukkah narrative. Who was she? What is her significance to us today?
In the second century B.C.E., as the powerful Assyrian army invades the Near East, the town of Bethulia is besieged by the cruel and domineering Holofernes, foremost general of the Assyrians . If Bethulia yields, the whole country will fall into Assyrian hands. Discouraged, the city's elders agree to surrender the famine-stricken city if they are not rescued within a few days. Judith, a young widow and most unlikely savior, challenges them to take responsibility for the future of their community. She enters the Assyrian camp where Holofernes, smitten with her remarkable beauty, invites her to a banquet. Judith, was a daughter of the Hasmoneans. She fed cheese to the leader of the enemies of the Jews. He was made thirsty by the cheese and began to drink much wine. When he grew quite drunk she cut off his head. For this reason, it was said, Jews eat cheese delicacies on Hanukkah With the Assyrian army thrown into confusion, Judith inspires the Israelites to launch a surprise attack from which they emerge victorious.
Behind every successful man, there is a strong patient guiding woman, and a surprised mother-in-law.
Many blessings,
Rabbi Dr. Arthur Segal
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Talmudic Discourse 20
Judy:
You're reading through romanticizing eyes. R. Zera was on the road a
lot...a latter day road warrior traveling between Israel and Babylonia...she
was obligated.
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Talmudic Discourse 19
Judy:
How is it extemporaneous?
Judy:
Please...you dont really agree with Rambam here do you? That on the whole, women are more spiritual, so they can do housework?!? GOSH NO RABBI JUDY. BUT UNTIL THE RAMBAM, FOR AT LEAST 1500 YEARS, JEWISH WOMEN WERE TOLD THEY WERE LIGHTING SHABBAT CANDLES TO MAKE UP FOR THE SIN OF EVE.
The Talmud contains quotes that may be seen as both laudatory and derogatory of women. The Talmud states that:
- Ten measures of speech descended to the world; women took nine Kiddushin 49b
- Women are "light on raw knowledge" — i.e. they possess more intuition Shabbat 33b (our dafs this week)
- A man without a wife lives without joy, blessing, and good; a man should love his wife as himself and respect her more than himself Yevamot 62b
- When Rav Joseph heard his mother's footsteps he would say: "Let me arise before the approach of the Skenhinah ('divine presence')" (Kiddushin 31b)
- Israel was redeemed from Egypt by virtue of its righteous women (Sotah 11b)
- A man must be careful never to speak slightingly to his wife because women are prone to tears and sensitive to wrong (Bava Metzia 59b)
- Women have greater faith than men (Sifre # 133)
- Women have greater powers of discernment (Niddah 45b)
- Women are especially tenderhearted (Megillah 14b)
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Talmudic Discourse 18
wayside?
how it goes ACTUALLY, RABBI ABRAMS, SADLY, I GET TO SAY THIS PRAYER, LESS AND LESS. JEWISH HOMES I WENT TO THIS WEEK, HAVE XMAS TREES, AND UNLIT CHANUKEAHS, IF THERE WAS A CHANUKEAH AT ALL. PERHAPS I SHOULD NOT CALL THEM JEWISH HOMES AS A RARELY SEE MEZUZOTH ON DOOR POSTS AS WELL. I END UP KISSING BARE WOOD.
1. What do you think of women being bound to do this mitzvah?
undermine the whole women dont do time-bound, positive mitsvot idea?
you think of other examples?
Happy Hannukkah! THANK YOU, AND TO YOU AND YOURS AS WELL. MANY BLESSINGS, RABBI DR ARTHUR SEGAL
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Judaism, Spirituality and Bluffton, SC
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Talmudic Discourses 17
The Talmud tackles this verse by contrasting it with the Almighty's instruction to Joshua: This book of the Torah shall not depart from your mouth (Joshua 1:8). From the directive to Joshua, we might conclude that we may never cease studying Torah. If this were the case, a person would be precluded from earning a livelihood. The promise of gathering produce teaches us that the all-encompassing obligation to study Torah retreats before the responsibility of gainfully employment.
One commentator explains that those who study Torah while relying on others to provide sustenance will eventually abandon their Torah study (Rashi, 11th century, France). Indeed, elsewhere our Sages teach that Torah which is not combined with work ultimately comes to naught and leads to sin (M. Avot 2:2). Torah study and earning a livelihood form a relationship which can be described as commensalism, where Torah derives benefit from work without adversely affecting it. To ensure that this book of the Torah shall not depart from our mouth, the Almighty tells us that we will gather our grain, our wine and our oil.
The approach of Torah and labor rendered by Rabbi Yishmael is juxtaposed with an opposing view, that of Rabbi Shimon ben Yohai: "If a person plows at the time of plowing, and sows at the time of sowing, and harvests at the time of harvesting, and threshes at the time of threshing, and winnows at the time when the wind blows - what will become of Torah?" Rabbi Shimon ben Yohai was concerned that if people were so busy earning a livelihood, this preoccupation with worldly matters would prevent Torah study. The relationship between Torah and labor can only be described as parasitical, for work preys on every moment of the day and relegates the pursuit of Torah to an unrealized ideal.
Rabbi Shimon ben Yohai therefore suggested a different modus operandi: "When Israel do the will of God, their work is done for them by others and indeed Torah need not depart from their mouths." This is indicated in the prophetic verse: "And strangers will arise and shepherd your flocks" (Isaiah 61:5).
Conversely, "when Israel do not do the will of the Almighty, their work must be done by themselves" and thus you will gather your grain, your wine and your oil. Moreover, Israel will do the work of others, as per the biblically described punishment "and you will serve your enemies" (Deuteronomy 28:48).
This model was practically applied by Rabbi Shimon ben Yohai during his years of hiding in a cave from the Roman authorities (B. Shabbat 33b). As he and his son sat buried to their necks in sand and solely occupied themselves with Torah study, water and carob sustenance was miraculously provided for them.
Thus our Sages suggest two conflicting models of the relationship between Torah and labor. According to one approach, earning a livelihood facilitates Torah study and both should be pursued. According to the other, working comes at the expense of Torah study and therefore should not be considered.
Fast forwarding a number of generations and moving to Babylon, the Talmud records two responses to this argument. The first response of Abbaye is an observation: "Many did as Rabbi Yishmael advocated - combining Torah study with work - and were successful; others did as Rabbi Shimon ben Yohai suggested and they were not successful."
The second response is Rava's entreaty to his disciples: "I beg of you, during the days of Nisan - when the grain is harvested - and the days of Tishrei - when the grapes and olives are pressed - do not appear before me so that you will not be preoccupied with your sustenance the entire year."
It would appear that the Talmud concludes in favor of the commensal approach promoted by Rabbi Yishmael. A thought must be spared, however, for uninterrupted study and total devotion to plumbing the scholarly depths of a discipline without financial burden. In many institutes of higher learning, scholarships are awarded with the goal of providing the student with an environment free of fiscal stress and strain. The hope is that students freed from economic concerns will be able to reach greater heights of scholarship, thus contributing to our society.
In this vein, later commentators focus on the exact formulation of Abbaye's observation: Rabbi Shimon ben Yohai's course was not fruitful for the many who tried to walk that path. Yet for a chosen few this route is certainly advocated, and from the standpoint of society we desire individuals who can totally devote themselves to scholarship. Of course this approach is not appropriate for all; it is a path that should be open only to suitable candidates.
Such people should be able to follow in the footsteps of Rabbi Shimon ben Yohai, removing themselves from this-worldly pursuits and devoting their entire beings to fathoming the depths of our tradition and unraveling its mysteries. The majority of people, however, are encouraged to see their labor as a necessary and desirable tool for Torah study.
Rabbi Yishmael may not have been describing a relationship of commensalism. While the commentators explain that work can benefit Torah study, Torah should also positively impact work. In a poetic formulation, our Sages declared: "If there is no flour, there is no Torah; if there is no Torah, there is no flour" (M. Avot 3:17), thus describing a symbiosis between Torah and earning a livelihood, where mutual benefit is derived from the association between Torah and labor.
Simply put, as the Chasidem, taught, all acts that we do each day should be aligned with God's will, and then all our acts become Holy, so even when Tevah milks his cow, in the Shalom Aleichem stories, he blesses God for creating such a creature.
Happy Thanks Giving:
Dr. Arthur Segal
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
Talmudic Discourses 16
1. New Study Materials: The California Fires, Katrina and Two Prayers to Say
At such times, sometimes our only
option is prayer. The Talmud, naturally, gives us an example of what
prayers we might offer at such a time:
Our Rabbis taught: Once all Israel went up on pilgrimage to Jerusalem, an=
d
they did not have water to drink. Nakdimon ben Guryon approached a certai=
n
governor, [and] said to him: Lend me twelve wells of water for the pilgri=
ms,
and I will give you twelve wells of water. And if I do not give [them] to
you, I will give you twelve talents of silver. And he set a time for him.
When the time arrived and the rain had not fallen, he sent to him in the
morning: Send me either the water or the money you owe me. He sent to him=
: I
still have time, [for] the entire day is mine.
At midday he sent to him: Send me either the water or the money that you =
owe
me. He sent to him: I still have time left in the day.
In the afternoon he sent to him: Send me the water or the money that you =
owe
me. He sent to him: I still have time left in the day. That governor snee=
red
at him [and] said: All year long rains have not fallen, and rains will fa=
ll
now? He entered the bathhouse joyfully.
As the lord entered the bathhouse joyfully, Nakdimon entered the Temple i=
n
sadness. He wrapped himself and stood in prayer. He said before Him: Mast=
er
of the Universe! It is revealed and known before You that I did not do
[this] for my [own] honor, nor did I do [it] for the honor of my father's
house. Rather, I did [it] for Your honor, so that water would be availabl=
e
for the pilgrims. Immediately the sky became covered with clouds and rain
fell until the twelve wells filled and overflowed.
As the lord left the bathhouse, Nakdimon ben Guryon left the Temple. When
they met each other, he said to him: Give me the money for the extra wate=
r
which you owe me. He said to him: I know that the Holy One blessed be He,
did not shake His world except on account of you. But I still have a clai=
m
against you that I may collect me money from you, for the sun has already
set and the rains fell in my possession.
He went back and entered the Temple, wrapped himself and stood in prayer,
and said before Him: Master of the Universe! Make it known that You have
loved ones in Your world. Immediately the clouds dispersed and the sun
shone. At that time the lord said to him: If the sun had not broken throu=
gh,
I would have had a claim against you that I could have collected my money
from you [but now, I cannot]. (B. Taanit 19b-20a)
=20
I love this story about Nakdimon ben Gurion for so many reasons. In the
present crisis, it=B9s a great example of leadership and proper prayer.
=20
Discussion Questions
1. Nakdimon first supplies what is needed, then he prays. How can we use
this as a model for acting in a crisis?
2. Nakdimon=B9s second prayer is most poignant. He does not ask for anyt=
hing
in specific=8Ahe can=B9t, as he is asking for something for himself and t=
hat
seems to go against his personal principles. Again, how can we use his
prayer as a model for prayer when we want to ask something of God but don=
=B9t
want to seem selfish?
=20
May the winds die down and the rains come soon!
Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.
